Should America prioritize strict immigration control over its identity as a nation of immigrants?

The United States has long been described as a nation of immigrants, built on the contributions of diverse cultures and peoples. However, recent political rhetoric—particularly under former President Trump—has shifted focus toward strict immigration control, border walls, and deportations. Supporters argue that this approach is necessary to protect American jobs, enhance national security, and maintain social cohesion, especially during times of economic uncertainty. They believe the unchecked influx of immigrants strains public services and undermines the social fabric. Opponents, on the other hand, stress that America’s strength lies in its history of openness and opportunity. They argue that harsh restrictions contradict the very values that built the nation, leading to racial profiling, fear, and division. As the country debates its future, the question remains: should immigration policy protect borders at all costs, or reflect the values of a diverse, welcoming society?